19oct08philosophy
The Amnesia Dilemma
Just like the Chocolate Dilemma earlier, another question has been bothering me lately. Consider this scenario:
Jack and Rose are a happily married couple. They are truly, madly, deeply in love. Adam, Rose’s college friend, has a thing for her but Rose is simply in love with Jack. Rose loses her memory in a freaky accident. The new Rose, though still Jack’s wife, has no feelings for Jack. In fact, she now loves Adam.
My question is – what’s the right thing? By right, I mean not only for Rose, but for, let’s say, the universe. Should Rose continue to be with Jack, or should she start a new life with Adam?
![[RSS]](http://blog.coffeebite.com/wp-includes/images/blank.gif)
gurpreet_fucker says...
i must say its vry difficult question. i think v shoud c this from jack’s point of view. as jack knows dat rose has no more feeling left for him, so he should let her love go to adams. dat vud be difficult but dats the best thing dat can be done in this situation in my opinion.
B says...
I think Jack shud try and win her over, if thats possible
But if thats not working then Rose shud stay with Adam-the one she loves now. There is no point of her staying with Jack*(someone she doesnt love now)